Fender vs Yamaha Guitar
Quick picks: budget, top pick and step-up
<strong>For an acoustic guitar, Yamaha is the better beginner buy; for an electric, Fender (and its Squier line) has the edge on name and resale value.</strong> Yamaha wins on consistent factory quality and the number of kids' sizes it offers, while Fender wins on brand appeal, which keeps some young players motivated. The comparison table below scores the two across eight factors.
Quick Answer:
Both are excellent choices for beginners. Yamaha offers slightly better value with consistent quality. Fender has the 'cool factor' and iconic status. For pure acoustic guitar quality at beginner prices, Yamaha often edges ahead. For electric guitar prestige, Fender is hard to beat.
| Factor | Fender | Yamaha |
|---|---|---|
| Brand Recognition | Iconic, 'cool' * | Respected, reliable |
| Beginner Acoustic Quality | Good | Excellent * |
| Electric Guitar Prestige | Industry standard * | Good value |
| Value for Money | Good | Excellent * |
| Kids' Size Options | Limited (FA-15, etc) | Many options * |
| Quality Control | Very Good | Excellent * |
| Resale Value | Higher * | Good |
| Teacher Recommendations | Common | Very Common |
Gear that goes with a acoustic guitar
* Indicates better option for that factor
Why Choose Fender
Fender excels at: brand appeal and motivation (the cool factor); electric guitars where Fender wrote the book; resale value; iconic designs kids recognize. A Squier by Fender electric guitar motivates many young players.
Why Choose Yamaha
Yamaha excels at: consistent quality across price points; acoustic guitar value; wide range of children's sizes; reliability and durability. The Yamaha FG/FS series are the benchmark beginner acoustics.
Making the Choice
For acoustic guitar: Yamaha typically offers better value and quality at beginner prices. For electric guitar: Both are excellent - Fender/Squier for rock appeal, Yamaha Pacifica for versatility. For children's guitars: Yamaha has more size options.
Our Verdict
For beginner acoustic guitars, Yamaha offers excellent value. For electric guitars, both are great - Fender has edge in cool factor, Yamaha in pure value. Either brand will serve beginners well.
Shop Both Options
Ready to start learning?
Guitar Tricks has 11,000+ lessons for all levels. Try it free for 14 days.
Related Comparisons
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for a beginner - Fender or Yamaha acoustic?
For acoustic guitars, Yamaha generally offers better quality at beginner price points. The Yamaha FG800 is a particularly excellent entry-level acoustic. Fender's acoustics are good but not their specialty.
Are Squier guitars (by Fender) good for kids?
Yes! Squier is Fender's affordable line and offers good quality. The Squier Mini Stratocaster is excellent for kids wanting electric guitar with the Fender name and look.
Which brand holds value better?
Fender products typically hold resale value better due to brand recognition. Yamaha guitars are excellent but don't command the same used prices. If you plan to resell, Fender has a slight edge.
Still not sure which is right for your child?
Take our quick quiz to get a personalized recommendation based on your child's unique situation.
Take the Free QuizFree, no email required