Electric Guitar Pack vs an Acoustic: The Real Total Cost
An electric guitar pack or an acoustic? The electric needs an amp and cable, which a pack includes. Compare the total, not the guitar price.
Quick Answer:
An electric guitar is easier to play than an acoustic, with lighter strings and lower action, and it needs an amplifier and a cable before it makes a sound. A starter pack bundles those, which is why comparing the pack price against a bare acoustic is the honest comparison. The acoustic needs nothing else and can be picked up and played in ten seconds, which matters more than people expect.
| Factor | Squier Affinity Stratocaster Pack | Fender CD-60S Acoustic |
|---|---|---|
| Total cost to first sound | Pack price, everything included | Guitar price only * |
| String tension | Lighter, easier on fingers * | Heavier |
| Practice with headphones | Yes, through the amp * | No |
| Setup time to play | Plug in, switch on | Pick it up * |
| Portability | Guitar plus amp | Guitar only * |
| Sound variety | Wide, with amp settings * | One natural voice |
| Motivation for a rock fan | High * | Moderate |
| Builds finger strength | Yes, gradually | Yes, faster * |
* Indicates better option for that factor
The cost comparison people get wrong
An electric guitar on its own makes almost no sound. The amplifier, the cable and often a strap are required rather than optional, which is why starter packs exist and why the pack price is the number to compare. Against a bare acoustic at a similar price, the pack looks more expensive, and it is including things the acoustic buyer will not need. Work out the total for each route before deciding which is cheaper.
Why electric is physically easier
Electric guitars use lighter gauge strings and typically have lower action and thinner necks, all of which mean less force to press a string down. For a beginner whose fingertips are not yet callused, that is a real difference in the first few weeks, which is exactly when most people stop. If finger pain is the concern, electric genuinely helps.
Where acoustic wins
An acoustic is always ready. There is no cable to find, no amp to switch on, and no volume decision, so it gets picked up in idle moments, and idle moments are where most practice actually happens. It is also easier to take to a lesson, a friend's house or a campfire. For a beginner whose main obstacle is consistency rather than finger pain, that convenience is worth a great deal.
The apartment question
An electric guitar through an amp with a headphone socket is silent to everyone else, which is a decisive advantage in a flat, a shared house or a home with young children asleep. An acoustic has one volume and it is not adjustable. If the practice time available is in the evening in a building with neighbours, this alone can settle the decision.
Our Verdict
Buy the electric pack if the player is motivated by rock or pop, if finger pain is a worry, or if silent practice matters. Buy the acoustic if simplicity and always being ready to play matter more, or if the guitar will travel. Both are legitimate first guitars, and the music the player actually likes is a better predictor of whether they keep going than either specification.
We review them on their own too, in full detail: the Squier Affinity Strat pack and the Yamaha FG800J .
The two instruments compared
Squier Affinity Stratocaster electric guitar pack
~$400
Check price on AmazonComparison based on published manufacturer specifications, current listings and the general consensus of verified owner reviews. We have not played these instruments ourselves and do not claim to have. Confirm current specifications and prices before buying. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Shop Both Options
Ready to start learning?
Guitar Tricks has 11,000+ lessons for all levels. Try it free for 14 days.
Related Comparisons
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you learn the same things on both?
Yes. Chords, scales, rhythm and reading are the same on both instruments and skills transfer almost completely. Someone who learns on one can pick up the other and be playing within an hour, allowing for the difference in string tension. Choosing one does not close off the other.
Is the amp in a starter pack any good?
It is a small practice amp, usually around ten watts, and it is adequate for a bedroom and not for playing with a drummer. That is the right amp for a beginner. It will be the first thing upgraded if the player continues, and there is no reason to spend more on an amp before that point.
Does an electric need more maintenance?
Slightly more parts and slightly less fuss. Strings need changing on both, an electric has electronics and a jack socket that can develop crackles, and an acoustic is more sensitive to humidity because the top is a thin piece of solid wood. Neither is demanding for a beginner.
How is this comparison researched?
From published specifications, current listings and the consensus of verified owner reviews, together with what music teachers publish about beginner instruments. We have not played these guitars ourselves and do not claim to have. Where the honest answer is that both options work, this page says so rather than manufacturing a winner.
Still not sure which is right for your child?
Take our quick quiz to get a personalized recommendation based on your child's unique situation.
Take the Free QuizFree, no email required